Jose Trevino

Sanskar Tiwari

Yankees’ Roster Shake-Up: Who Shouldn’t Make The Cut In 2024?

The New York Yankees are gearing up for the 2024 season with determination after falling short of the postseason in 2023, marking their first absence from playoff contention since 2016. With an 82-80 record, the Yankees faced disappointment but are poised to bounce back stronger. However, to achieve success, they must strategically build their roster to overcome challenges, including injuries and underperforming players. Here’s a closer look at three players who may not make the 40-man roster this season based on their recent performances and the team’s needs.

Jose Trevino’s Struggles

Catcher Jose Trevino has been with the Yankees since 2022 but has failed to make a significant impact offensively. While he showcases solid defensive skills behind the plate, his offensive contributions have been lacking. Over the past two years, the 31-year-old has struggled to generate consistent production, recording just 16 doubles, 15 home runs, and 58 RBIs in 492 at-bats.


Trevino’s 2023 season was particularly challenging, as he endured a right-wrist surgery that prematurely ended his year. Prior to the injury, his slash line stood at .210/.257/.312, highlighting his offensive struggles. With better offensive options available on the trade market, it may be time for the Yankees to part ways with Trevino and seek an upgrade at the catcher position.

Jose Trevino
Yankees/Jose Trevino

Third baseman Jordan Groshans, acquired via waivers from the Miami Marlins, is another player whose spot on the roster is in question. Despite being a highly touted prospect drafted 12th overall by the Toronto Blue Jays, Groshans has yet to translate his potential into consistent on-field performance.

During the 2023 season, Groshans struggled offensively, posting a .243/.339/.330 slash line over 528 plate appearances with Miami’s Triple-A affiliate. With only six home runs and limited extra-base hits, the 24-year-old has yet to demonstrate the offensive prowess expected of him. While he may benefit from further development in the minors, the Yankees require immediate impact players to bolster their roster.

Luke Weaver’s Reliability Concerns

Pitcher Luke Weaver’s one-year deal with the Yankees comes with uncertainty, given his inconsistent performance in recent seasons. Weaver’s 2023 campaign saw him bouncing between multiple teams, including the Cincinnati Reds and the Seattle Mariners, before landing in New York. Although he showed glimpses of potential with the Yankees, recording 16 strikeouts and a 3.38 ERA in 13.1 innings, his overall season was marred by inconsistency.

Luke Weaver
Yankees/Luke Weaver

Throughout his eight-year career, Weaver has struggled to maintain a consistent level of performance, as evidenced by his career ERA of 5.14. With the Yankees in need of reliable bullpen arms, Weaver’s track record raises concerns about his ability to consistently deliver in high-pressure situations.

As the New York Yankees prepare for the 2024 season, they face critical decisions regarding their roster composition. With the goal of returning to postseason contention, the team must prioritize players who can make an immediate impact and address areas of weakness. While players like Jose Trevino, Jordan Groshans, and Luke Weaver have shown promise at various points, their recent performances raise doubts about their suitability for the upcoming season. As the team navigates the challenges ahead, tough decisions may be necessary to ensure a competitive roster capable of achieving success in the highly competitive landscape of Major League Baseball.