The New York Yankees are facing a tough decision this offseason as they evaluate the future of long-time infielder DJ LeMahieu. Once the anchor of their lineup, LeMahieu’s recent struggles have cast doubt on his role with the team. With $30 million remaining on his contract through 2026, the Yankees must decide if they’ll stick with their versatile veteran or move on as they reshape their roster for 2025.
From MVP Contender To Uncertainty
LeMahieu was a force to be reckoned with during his prime. In 2020, he led the American League with a blistering .364 batting average and seemed destined for long-term success in pinstripes. Fast forward to 2024, and the narrative has shifted. Battling injuries and inconsistent play, LeMahieu managed just a .243 batting average with a .327 on-base percentage—far below the elite numbers fans had come to expect.
Injuries, including nagging foot and hip issues, have limited his availability and effectiveness. Despite his struggles, Yankees General Manager Brian Cashman believes LeMahieu still has something to offer. “He’s a pro. I expect him to be healthy and ready to prove himself in camp,” Cashman said, signaling that spring training will be critical for LeMahieu’s future.
Is It Time To Move On?
Not everyone shares Cashman’s optimism. Analysts like Chris Kirschner from The Athletic argue that LeMahieu’s hefty contract has become a sunk cost. “If his spring performance mirrors the last two seasons, the Yankees should consider designating him for assignment,” Kirschner wrote.
This bold move would mean eating the remaining $30 million of LeMahieu’s contract—no small feat. However, the Yankees have shown they’re willing to prioritize performance over payroll in the past. Just last season, the team parted ways with outfielder Aaron Hicks, despite owing him $27 million. That decision cleared space for more productive roster options, a precedent that could influence LeMahieu’s fate.
A New Direction For The Yankees?
LeMahieu’s versatility has been a cornerstone of his value, providing defensive depth across the infield. Yet, with the Yankees aggressively pursuing new talent this offseason, including their headline-grabbing signing of Paul Goldschmidt, there’s a sense that the roster is moving in a younger, more dynamic direction. Prospects and acquisitions could make LeMahieu’s role less essential, leaving the team with a difficult choice.
What’s Next For DJ And The Yankees?
As the Yankees prepare for spring training, all eyes will be on LeMahieu. Can he bounce back and prove he’s still a valuable contributor, or will the Yankees take the hit and move on? One thing is clear: this decision could set the tone for the team’s 2025 season.
What do you think the Yankees should do? The countdown to the season is on, and whether DJ LeMahieu is part of the Yankees’ future remains one of the biggest questions in the Bronx.
Stay tuned with Sports News International for more such updates about your favorite MLB team