The New York Yankees are entering a critical offseason, with holes to fill across their lineup and a renewed focus on returning to World Series glory. Among their top priorities, including the bullpen, is addressing the first base position, which underperformed significantly in 2024.
After declining Anthony Rizzo’s option, the New York Yankees have signaled their intent to explore new possibilities at the position. Whether or not the Bombers secure Juan Soto, upgrading at first base is essential to solidify the lineup and provide much-needed offensive firepower. Here are three top-tier free agents the team should consider for first base.
1. Pete Alonso
Pete Alonso, a homegrown star for the crosstown New York Mets, is one of the most exciting options on the market. Known for his prodigious power, Alonso has consistently delivered elite production since his rookie year in 2019, when he smashed a record-breaking 53 home runs. In five full MLB seasons, Alonso has never dipped below 30 homers, boasting a career slash line of .246/.331/.472.
At 30, Alonso is in his prime and has entrusted super-agent Scott Boras to secure him a massive contract. His offensive consistency and power make him a dream fit for Yankee Stadium’s short right-field porch. However, Alonso’s price tag will likely be steep, especially with reports of him rejecting a $158 million extension from the Mets. While expensive, Alonso would instantly transform the Yankees’ lineup and inject some intercity rivalry drama.
2. Christian Walker
Christian Walker offers a more budget-friendly yet highly effective alternative. The 33-year-old has quietly become one of the most reliable first basemen in the league, combining solid offensive production with elite defense. Walker has won consecutive Gold Gloves (2022-2023) and has posted an OPS above .800 in each of the last three seasons.
Walker’s blend of power, consistency, and defensive prowess would be a perfect fit for the Yankees, especially as they look to maintain roster flexibility for other key acquisitions. His leadership and experience could also add a valuable dimension to the clubhouse. For a team prioritizing value without sacrificing quality, Walker may be the best option.
3. Paul Goldschmidt
Paul Goldschmidt, a former MVP and perennial All-Star, is also available. While the 37-year-old is coming off the worst season of his illustrious career, with a slash line of .242/.302/.412, his track record suggests he could bounce back in a new environment.
Goldschmidt’s veteran presence and proven ability to thrive under pressure could make him a short-term solution while the New York Yankees continue to develop their younger prospects. If the price is right, taking a chance on the six-time All-Star could pay dividends.
That being said, other names on the market include Carlos Santana, Yuli Gurriel, Dom Smith, and former Yankee Joey Gallo. While these players could provide depth or platoon options, the New York Yankees will likely aim higher to secure a first baseman who can anchor the lineup. Overall, as the Bronx Bombers retool for 2025, the first base position represents a critical opportunity to strengthen their roster.
Stay tuned with Sports News International for more such updates about your favorite MLB team